Quest help(really nooby)

[imported_DarkArtWiz]

Ok this is a retarded question, but how am I supposed to beat the fishing contest quest? I feel so noobish, but anyway, i used the garlic on the wall pipe and then went to fish, and the sinister dude won anyway at my old spot. It's driving mne insane, can anyone help?

[imported_hihihihihhi]

i think ur supposed to fish first, talk to sinister, then talk to him
then.... use ur garlic on the pipes
then u can catch 2 or 3 carps and bonzo will call u the winner

[imported_DarkArtWiz]

thanks but I forgot about the red worms haha, but i beat it so this topic can be closed.

[pukacdoohch]

well im wanting to alert you that i put i guide just want to say...